Irish Media’s Coverage Of State Papers Just Not Good Enough

UPDATE – See comment below from on UVF letter. The blog specialises in covering Loyalist paramilitary matters. It echoes my reservations re the UVF letter to Haughey……


At the end of December or beginning of January every year we go through the  ritual of reading reports about what the government of the day thirty years ago said or believed about this or that. Sometimes the subject matters deal with very important events; very often they keep the juicy bits from view.

We get to read the reports in The Irish Times or watch/listen to them on RTE but we never actually get to see the documents themselves, so we can a) read the whole thing and not depend on the judgement of some reporter whose beat may normally be something entirely different; or b) make up our own minds about the credibility of the source.

That is especially the case this year when we were told that the UVF had written a letter back in 1987 to then Taoiseach Charles Haughey stating that MI5 had allegedly incited the UVF to assassinate him and that they had also supplied the detonators in the bombs which killed the Miami Showband in 1975 (the bombs also exploded prematurely killing the UVF bombers).

Now I have never, in all my years covering the Troubles, seen or heard of the UVF sending letters, never mind one to an Irish prime minister. What does a letter with UVF letterhead look like? What address do they give? How did the government of the day check its authenticity? Did anyone bother to drive up the Shankill to ask? Is it a real letter or an elaborate hoax? I’d like to know and seeing a copy of the original would help me, and other readers/viewers decide.

In this age of smart phones and iPads/tablets equipped with sophisticated cameras there is no excuse for newspapers and TV companies not to demand from the government the right to reproduce the documents in their entirety. Very little bureaucratic hassle would follow and they are, after all, the peoples’ papers. They have a right to see them, even if only on the publication’s website. It happens here in the US routinely, so why not in Ireland?

4 responses to “Irish Media’s Coverage Of State Papers Just Not Good Enough

  1. Totally agree. Again we are being stage managed both by Government and unfortunately the media. How come the Government has sat on secrets for 30 yrs and not done a damn thing about it? If this is the real world I would highly suspect some type of subterfuge. Again why are the gombeen men of this little Island imitating the darker forces of imperialism? Maybe they a little insecure or they want to be like the big boys. Or maybe they are like the big boys and are hiding their dirty washing. What is the reason for this secrecy anyway? If I hear another politician spouting ‘openness and transparency’ I’ll throw the Dáil and civil service at them. It gets worse because we know that even even after all the time while the secrets have gathered dust we are only getting half truths.

  2. Pingback: Irish Media’s Coverage Of State Papers Just Not Good Enough – seachranaidhe1

  3. A slight tangent, but a very compelling interview with Miami Showband survivor, Steven Travers, and George Galloway. Enjoy.

  4. It is one of the most preposterous, not to mention irresponsible, stories I’ve read relating to the UVF, worse even than the recent nonsense about Robin Jackson being responsible for over 120 murders (which would effectively mean he had carried out nearly every UVF killing outside Belfast during the conflict).

    I feel confident in saying that 30 years ago no serious reporter or editor would have run with this story, not without a recognised codeword and not without running it past their paramilitary contacts.

    If I had to make a guess as to the letter’s origins, I’d say it was a hoax carried out by someone in the unionist community who was angry about the Anglo-Irish Agreement and wanted to stir the pot between the two governments. It just raises too many first-sight, common sense objections, not even counting those that come with a knowledge of the UVF’s history and way of operating.

Leave a Reply to Lauren Alder (@LaurenAlder) Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.