Within an hour of hearing the news that Maggie Thatcher had died I logged on to Sinn Fein’s website to see what the Provos were saying about the woman and her political legacy. The BBC World Service had made a passing reference to negative comments having been made by Gerry Adams but no more detail than that.
Given that she was, at least in popular perception, the most consequential and divisive of British prime ministers during the Troubles in Northern Ireland but that at least part of her story – the bit dealing with the hunger strikes of 1981 – has been considerably revised and challenged in the decades since, I was eager to see just exactly what the Sinn Fein leadership was saying about her.
But what caught my attention was not what was said about the 1981 protest that led to ten prison deaths – and there was very little dealing with that – but Gerry Adams’ concluding remark: “Her Irish policy failed miserably.”
It caught my eye because I had to scroll down the page to get to the Adams’ statement and in the process I noticed this headline: ‘Carrier Bag Proposer Welcomes Introduction’. It was a story about how Daithi McKay, a Sinn Fein Assembly member from North Antrim had successfully introduced a new law in the Northern Ireland Assembly at Stormont imposing a levy of five pence on plastic carrier bags supplied by supermarkets.
His proposal won sufficient cross party support to become law and as Mr McKay put it: “(The levy) has been enormously successful in the rest of Ireland and I expect that it will also lead to a significant reduction in the number of carrier bags being used in the north.”
Now don’t get me wrong. I hate plastic supermarket bags as much as the next man (and I live with someone who insists on hoarding the damn things!) so anything that helps get rid of them must be good. Nothing is more unsightly than this industrial equivalent of tumbleweed; it gets blown everywhere and has an annoying knack of getting caught on wire fences, visually blighting working class housing estates in particular.
So fair play to Daithi McKay. But I just couldn’t see how what he had achieved could sit comfortably with Gerry Adams’ claim that Margaret Thatcher’s Ireland policy had failed miserably.
What I mean by that is this: if you had said to Maggie Thatcher back in 1981 that as a result of her stance during the hunger strikes, or at least her stance as it was successfully depicted to their supporters by Sinn Fein, the Provos were able to move into electoral politics and channel all that resulting Nationalist anger into votes and that as a consequence within a decade or so there would be a unilateral IRA ceasefire and a peace process that would lead to the IRA destroying its own weapons, Sinn Fein becoming ministers in a power-sharing government in Belfast and Daithi McKay proudly proclaiming his achievement in persuading his Unionist colleagues at Stormont to impose a five pence levy on plastic bags, and all this without even a hint of a threat to Northern Ireland’s Finchley-like Britishness, Maggie Thatcher might well feel entitled to say: “If that is what failing miserably looks like, then give me more!”
I’ve never been an admirer of the Iron Lady, in fact, quite the opposite. Her coldblooded intransigence in dealing with the Hunger Strikers generated worldwide sympathy and support for them and resulted in the election of Bobby Sands to British Parliament and Sinn Fein’s move into electoral politics. Reflecting on the unanticipated rise of Sinn Fein must have caused Margaret Thatcher some consternation. Her attempts to crush the Hunger Strikers in fact, liberated them–and the Peace Process evolved– but not because of Thatcher’s good intentions.
You’ve completely missed the point of this article haven’t you? It was because she was so intransigent and ,the resulting Sinn Fein success at the ballot box, that the more imaginative and far-sighted republicans were able to persuade the lunatics that they could not win militarily but that they could have real success through the ballot-box
A good analysis and a positive perspective on Sinn Fein’s rise from the Armalite to the ballot box. I definitely thought i wouldn’t have seen this transition by Sinn Fein in my lifetime !
Her ‘contribution’ to Irish politics will no doubt form a grisly footnote. I’ll always rember her craven support for General Pinochet, US dirty wars in Central America and ‘Democratic Kampuchea (Pol Pot) in Asia.
Her disastrous domestic legacy almost pales into insignificance.
An excellent and balanced post and I’m not a little pleased to be able to say that it was almost exactly what occurred to me when I heard Adams’s; comments about the failure of her “Irish policy”. Failure indeed!
On the other hand, had she been seen to cave in to terrorist blackmail then the Provo’s hand would have been strengthened immeasurably, they would have been emboldened by the almost certain fall of the British Government leading to the success of the hard-liners and the side-lining of those wanting to end the “war” and of course, even more killing and maiming.