The Broken Elbow

Thanks to RS for the tip. You can read it here.

By James Kinchin-White

(I have been meaning to post this for some time but other matters intervened. It is a great piece, well worth the read – EM)

The effect of Britain’s colonial past is key to understanding the often disastrous impact of political policy and military tactics on the Northern Ireland Troubles between 1970-75 (the definitive years that established the relationship between the community and the British army).

The origin, structure and tactics of British covert forces during that early period of Operation Banner (the longest deployment of the British Army in history) can be traced back to their operations in Palestine, Malaya, Kenya, Cyprus and Aden.

In the early 1920s, RIC, Auxiliaries and Black and Tans recruited directly from Ireland provided the backbone for the British Palestinian Gendarmerie. Records show that many of these men were approached for recruitment while still serving in Ireland and eventually numbered over 700.

The British Gendarmerie morphed into the Palestinian Police ater 1926 and from this one of the first covert reaction units (as opposed to a purely intelligence gathering unit) was led by then Captain Ord Wingate in 1938.
Wingates ‘Special Night Squads’ subsequently became the model adopted by Nicol Grey (Inspector General Palestine Police 1946-48 and former Lt. Col. Royal Marine Commando WWII)

Grey appointed Brigadier Bernard Fergusson in 1947 to recruit ex British special forces officers to lead the new ‘Special Squads’. One was led by then Captain Roy Farran and the other by Captain Alistair McGregor (father of Captain Hamis McGregor who was to be one of the commanders of the highly controversial Mobile Reaction Force (MRF) in Belfast in 1972).

The Palestine Special Squads used tactics that would not be dissimilar to those subsequently employed by the MRF and in a further extraordinary anecdotal episode, the then Lt. Colin Mitchell of the Argyle and Sutherland Highlanders (later better known as Mad Mitch of Aden and Crater fame 1967), was involved in ‘procuring’ a Laundry Van for the Special Squads to use for covert surveillance and transport.

It was the subsequent use of a Laundry Van by the MRF in Belfast that was to partly lead to the units downfall. In MRFs Four Square Laundry operation, Sapper Ted Stewart, from Strabane, and Lance Corporal Sarah Jane Warke were ambushed in Turf Lodge after the operation had been discovered by PIRA intelligence. Stewart was killed and Warke narrowly escaped.

Following the withdrawal from Palestine in 1948, around 500 former British Palestinian Police were recruited to form a ‘Special Constrbulary’ in Malya while others were sent to Kenya (the latter included one of the two Palestinian ‘Special Squad’ Sergeants who assisted Farran to escape from custody during his flight from the consequences of the murder of Alexander Rubowitz (Ceserani, 2009).

During the Troubles, the construction of border (and urban) fortresses were a mere modernization of the ‘Tegart Forts’ built in Palestine and their purpose was virtually identical. (see: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-19019949). Somewhat ironically, Charles Tegart was born in Derry and though the Troubles era structures have largely been demolished, Tegart’s Palestinian Forts have survived and now lie mostly within the borders of Israel.
According the the BBC, Tegart had other ‘colonial skills’:

His methods wouldn’t stand up to much modern scrutiny. Long before the world hit upon the euphemism “enhanced interrogation techniques“, he was reputed to take a violent and uncompromising way with detainees.

The first troops deployed in Derry on 14 August 1969 unfurled their ‘Do not cross this line’ banners perhaps to the bemusement of the crowd since they were written in Arabic and last used in Aden (Major M. Sullivan, Prince of Wales Own Regiment of Yorkshire in Walsh, A. 2015 ‘Belfast 69’).

There is a wealth of such information that connects British colonial policy and military tactics with the debacle that was the early period of Op Banner and which must take a major share of the causes of a war that went on far too long.

From Axios

Matt Taibii punctures the Joe Biden balloon. You can read it here.

Ever wondered what happened to the Black and Tans after the Treaty was signed in 1921? Well, here’s your answer. They went to Palestine, first to put the boot into the Jews and then into the Arabs. Plus ca change…..Thanks to MM for the tip.

Great piece by Kevin Myers, and a useful reminder of how the Paras behaved in working class areas of the North (and as Loyalists of that date can attest they were as brutal on the Shankill or lower Newtowards Rd as they were in Ballymurphy). You can read the piece here.

https://www.newyorker.com/news/annals-of-populism/a-liberal-zionists-move-to-the-left-on-the-israeli-palestinian-conflict?utm_source=nl&utm_brand=tny&utm_mailing=TNY_Daily_052321&utm_campaign=aud-dev&utm_medium=email&bxid=5dab9ad44b2ef4248273c24a&cndid=58948056&hasha=ce1cac6edfe9296e95c3f72f6f06e215&hashb=3c762eddfd463b44477c10c278f7103e0b67ed6b&hashc=38aab6128bcb56dd8423e3648e3a435e07dfff85e99544e00789be4f0f25264f&esrc=AUTO_PRINT&utm_term=TNY_Daily

For readers unfamiliar with New York, the Diamond district is in midtown Manhattan, 47th Street and Fifth Avenue and is strongly Jewish……(thanks to MMG for the tip)

This article is important not just for its content but because it appeared in The New York Times, for long regarded as one of America’s least Israel-critical newspapers. Netanyahu’s government in Tel Aviv would be foolish not to take note. The content is disturbing not least because it is reminiscent of the sort of organised thuggery that German Nazis deployed against Jews as a prelude to the holocaust. You can read it here.

That is the description which appears more than any other in the vast majority of reports worldwide about the recent violence meted out against the Palestinians of Gaza. Israel treats the people under its control in Gaza in the same way as white South Africans dealt with their Black subjects – with contempt, disproportionate violence and arrogance. Israel had got away with it so often, it assumed it would be the same this time. Big mistake. The lesson to Hamas is straightforward: stop while you’re ahead. You’ve won this battle hands down. The game is yours to lose.