I have just learned that Brian Moore, better known as the cartoonist Cormac, died recently in Belfast and reading some of the obits that appeared on the web and elsewhere, it struck me that his role in the development of republican, that is Provo republican, politics was not really given proper recognition by the various writers. He played a small part, for sure, but nonetheless an important one in its way in bringing about the leadership changes in the IRA and Sinn Fein that led us to where we are now.
He was originally a member of one of those Trotskyite groups – don’t ask me which one, but I have a notion it was an offshoot of the post-QUB, Peoples Democracy – which believed that national liberation struggles were more important than class ones, that supporting the Viet Cong and Che Guevara was more relevant than organising in the local Ford plant or giving out leaflets during strikes. In Ireland that meant backing the Provos and so it was that Brian Moore volunteered his services as cartoonist for Republican News and later An Phoblacht-Republican News (AP-RN).
As a cartoonist Brian Moore was strongly influenced by the American underground comix tradition of the late 1960’s and early 1970’s which was especially rich in the San Francisco area. That was no accident since San Francisco was at the centre of the Sixties counterculture ferment which was defined by political radicalism, disdain for mainstream values and liberal attitudes towards sex and drug use, all themes that were meat and drink in the world of underground comix.
The comix were mostly self-published and although they had small circulations the cultural influence of publications like Zap Comix and characters like Fritz the Cat or the Fabulous Furry Freak Brothers was immense and stretched way beyond the west coast. One of the best of the underground cartoonists was Robert Crumb whose work and that of Brian Moore are strikingly similar. Two of Crumb’s creations, Mr Natural and Keep on Truckin’ could easily have jumped out of a Brian Moore cartoon in AP/RN or vice-versa.
It was Danny Morrison who as editor in the mid-1970’s brought Brian Moore into Republican News, the Provisional weekly that was set up by the Belfast Brigade of the IRA in 1970 under the direction of Jimmy Steele and Hugh McAteer, the latter a former Chief of Staff, the former an early Provo icon and veteran of the Thirties and Forties campaigns.
The early Republican News was almost a caricature of the early Provisionals and faithfully reflected the devout Catholicism and fierce anti-Communism of the new IRA’s founders. One of its first editorials railed against erstwhile comrades in the Official IRA, explaining the reasons why people of the calibre of Steele and McAteer had broken with them to set up the Provisional IRA in terms that Joe McCarthy would have been proud of: “Gradually into executive posts both in the IRA and Sinn Fein, the Red agents infiltrated and soon these men became the policy makers”. Its first editor later became a leader in the Tridentine Mass movement which was dedicated to returning the Catholic church to Latin rituals and the dogmas and attitudes of pre-Vatican II Catholicism.
By the time Brian Moore joined Republican News, both Steele and McAteer were dead and the IRA in Belfast was moving leftwards under the direction of Gerry Adams, Ivor Bell and Brendan Hughes whose influence was enormously significant even though all three men were in Long Kesh at the time, either as internees or jailed because of escape attempts from internment.
The IRA had just ended a long, debilitating ceasefire which had caused huge dissension within the organisation. The camp led by Adams, Bell and Hughes – then the IRA’s Young Turks – opposed the ceasefire, arguing that the leadership in Dublin had been tricked by the British into believing that withdrawal was on the cards. Instead, they said, the British had used the lengthy ceasefire to build up intelligence on the IRA and to refine their anti-terrorist strategy, notably by criminalising the IRA, which almost resulted in its defeat.
Danny Morrison had at first supported the 1974-75 ceasefire but was talked round by Adams and then became an enthusiastic convert to the anti-leadership cause. Adams & Co. were agitating to take over the IRA and the centerpiece of their argument was the conviction that a quick military victory was no longer possible, that the war against the British was going to be a long one and to survive that length of time, the IRA would need to become politically relevant to those from whom it drew support. That necessitated both that the IRA move leftwards and that it get involved politically, two ideas that not only would have been anathema to Jimmy Steele and Hugh McAteer and their confreres but contained within them the mustard seeds of the peace process.
Under Morrison’s editorship, Republican News became the vehicle for this agenda. Gerry Adams and like-minded IRA prisoners were given columns in the paper. Adams chose the Brownie byline (for a detailed explanation, see Voices From the Grave) to protect his anonymity as he pushed his programme, although everyone knew it was him, but others also wrote influential columns, not least Bobby Sands under the nom de plume, Marcella.
Hiring Brian Moore was an inspired move by Morrison and along with allowing the late John McGuffin, a friend and colleague of Moore’s, free rein to write The Brigadier column, an often hilarious send up of the British Army’s officer class, these moves helped make Republican News one of the most attractive and interesting political papers in Western Europe. The Cormac cartoon though was its distinctive feature and as Danny Morrison noted in his obituary of Moore it was often the first thing that readers would turn to.
The contrast represented by Morrison’s Republican News with the staid leadership that had led the IRA into the ceasefire disaster, old men with politics to match, could not have been greater. They were yesterday’s men, out of touch and out of date, whereas Adams & Co., as symbolised by their newspaper, were tomorrow’s young, vibrant and relevant hope for Irish republicans, people who were brimming with ideas and enthusiasm. In the world of political propaganda, hiring Brian Moore and transforming RN was the equivalent of ditching Thompson machine guns for Armalite rifles.
It was no accident either that when Gerry Adams made his move in the late 1970’s to consolidate the take over of the IRA that he and his allies had been long planning, they chose the organisation’s newspapers as a major battleground. In those days RN’s circulation was confined to the North; the IRA’s Southern supporters were sold An Phoblacht (The Republic) which was produced in Dublin and strongly reflected the views of the anti-Adams Southern leadership.
Adams’ victory, and his readiness to wade in the gutter to achieve it, was signaled when, after a fierce battle that involved badly smearing AP’s editor Gerry O’Hare, the two papers were fused. Any doubt as to who had won were settled when the first edition of the re-christened An Phoblacht-Republican News appeared. It was Republican News, in content, style and politics, with a slightly different name; An Phoblacht had been swallowed up and was no more. In this bitter little battle Brian Moore and Cormac had played a not insignificant role.
But what goes around, comes around. I doubt very much whether Danny Morrison’s observation remained correct throughout time and that when AP-RN moved into what can only be described as its Pyongyang Times phase, when pro-peace process political correctness became the stifling order of the day, people still as enthusiastically turned to the Cormac cartoon.
The truth is that, at the end, his cartoons became infected with the same malady, faithfully drawn to conform to that week’s orthodoxy. The cartoon chosen by AP-RN to accompany his obituary was typical of this, celebrating Stormont, once the symbol of partition and a prime target for destruction by the IRA, but now the Holy Grail partly because Sinn Feiners sit in its chamber but mostly because Unionists don’t like that. The cartoon is also, interestingly, a measure of how much sectarianism is now part of the Provo culture. In fact AP-RN became so dull that it is no longer sold as a newspaper, hawked as it once was, door-to-door by volunteers and is now only available on the web where it is read by an ever dwindling audience.
There was, though, another aspect of Brian Moore’s life that is worth remembering and that was as songwriter and performer for the Men of No Property, an eclectic group which produced original pro-IRA music and songs in the early 1970’s. Two of Moore’s creations, the self-explanatory England’s Vietnam and Jesus and Jesse, the story of Jesus Christ and Jesse James meeting in the Belfast of the early 1970’s, have become classics and also relics of what now seems to be a long-lost age. Their music is still on sale here. Here are those two songs for you to savour:
I prefer the old Brian Moore’s politics – my favourite People of No Property song was Tuten Carson’s Tomb, a savage mockery of Stormont – “After the revolution, I often wondered about the impressions of explorers when they came into a jungle clearing and discovered Stormont, the ancient seat of power of the Orange monolith. What priceless pieces of booty will the Fermanagh Pharaoh Harry West and the Sun King Twisted-Mouth Faulkner leave posterity when the old regime crumbles into the dustbin of history?”
“Those hieroglyphics on the wall
Told the story of the great downfall.
Every year when the 12th did come
They put on a sash and beat a Cambeg drum.
Remember 1690 were the cries,
The last time the workers in Belfast got a rise.
For fifty years they’d had their fun
Till Stormount fell in ’71.
They tried again in ’73,
But the people said no, we want to be free.”
Maybe in 2023 we can bring Stormont down again – for the last time!
Brian was a member of the Revolutionary Marxist Group in the 1970’s – he left a couple of years after I joined in 1974 and became part of the Sinn Féin “family”. The Stormont cartoon in Ed’s piece above can be compared with the sentiments of Tuten Carson’s Tomb – very different politics, very different eras. He also drew some beautiful cartoons in the British International Marxist Group Newspaper Socialist Challenge in the late 1970’s and1980’s. He made hsi mark on life and will be missed.
Hi Ed. Thats not correct as regards the paper. It effectively dropped the ‘republican news’ handle in roughly 03-06 (not sure entirely when, but I know its gone. It became simply an Phoblacht. Due to dropping paper sales the paper was changed from a weekly to a monthly, and has since increased its sales in a healthy enough way. Sales remain comparatively weak in areas where SF produces regular local freesheet papers (belfast and Armagh notably) but better in Dublin, Cork etc. No idea how the website is faring, although it is quite a good site, but just think that it should be clarified that it is still going, and gradually recovering.
I think that you miss the point of the cartoon depicting Stormount, Brian Moore was absolutely not sectarian minded quite the opposite in fact. I grew up around Brian and was lucky to have known him my whole life being as he and my father were very good friends, you are correct that Brian was a socialist and when buried his coffin bore the red flag, also Brian was known for singing the song Joe McCann about an Official I.R.A man from the Markets area in Belfast, he also sung the song Slan libh a song saying farewell to Billy Mc Kee another member of the O.I.R.A.
I think you underestimate greatly Brian’s role in the struggle and his contribution to it.
Being the kind of guy he was im sure he would have a little chuckle at your insinuation. Brian was a friend of the worker as can be heard in the song Island men, he didn’t care what their religion was or where they were from
I rather think you entirely missed the point about the cartoon. stormont was an assembly that the provo leaders had sworn to destroy because it symbolised partition so when they took their seats and then ministerial posts they had to justify this rather considerable about-face to their own rank and file and so what brian helped them do was to peddle the line that now stormont had so many sf members in it, it was okay, it made partition acceptable. which begs all sorts of questions, one being, well if that is all that was ever wrong did that justify twenty years of bombing and shooting? had nothing to do with sectarianism, of which brian was certainly an opponent. at the end though he did become a shill for the shinners and for a political philosophy i am not certain he was comfortable with. by the way billy mckee was never in OIRA> he was the first belfast commander of the provos and went on to be on their army council. he may have been many things but billy mckee was never a stick.
Ed, it seems that I have been out of belfast too long and got my Billy’s mixed up, it was in fact Billy McMillen i was refering to and not McKee.
I do though take offence to you calling him a shill, the Republican Movement at the time of the ceasefires was in the position if they continued the war they stood to lose more than what they could ever gain politically, i know that a lot of people outwith the Movement were begining to show indifference to the war and the I.R.A/Sinn Fein, the opportunity was there for Sinn Fein to make a much larger difference through the ballot box than they were ever going to make militarily and i think Brian realised it was his responsibility to ensure the leadership message got across as it also was when the war was ramping up.
I was born in old Ardoyne and saw my fair share of sectarianism when i was a kid, i remember loyalists attacking and burning everything that stood in their way, there was no way that was going to stop without the extra 20 years of fighting that took place, you can even see today the loyalist mind set when you look at the Rangers situation, it seems that they feel a certain superiority, the we will do what we like and get away with it, something had to be done to stop that and the Government at the time surely wasn’t going to they were helping them with the “B” Specials and the UDR.
yes, as you say, you have been out of belfast too long.